In case you haven’t heard, The A.V. Club is making the jump to broadcast television and launching our very own TV show. Hosted by editor-at-large and part-time LensCrafters model John Teti, the show will provide the same mixture of humor and pop culture acumen you’ve come to expect from the A.V. Club brand.

Get a taste of what’s in store from the clip above, where we try to figure out who the hell watches NCIS. The A.V. Club show premieres tonight at 9 p.m. Eastern on Fusion.