If you haven’t heard yet, Double Dare returned to Nickelodeon earlier this summer, the cable network’s second attempt at reviving the family game show. While the basic formula remains the same—two teams compete to win prizes by answering trivia questions and completing the notoriously smelly obstacle course—they’ve brought along a handful of celebrities to compete, like former Nick stars Lori Beth Denberg and Kel Mitchell, and tapped popular YouTube personality Liza Koshy to host. On the set of the revival, we spoke with Mitchell, Koshy, Denberg, and original host Marc Summers about the show and why now is the perfect time for a comeback.