When we were asked to beautiful Marina Del Rey, California to hang out on a party barge with the cast of TBS’ Wrecked, we jumped at the chance—provided, that is, that we could ask them whatever silly questions we wanted. Given that the show is a comedy about a group of travelers stranded on a desert island, we figured we’d go with a tried and true query: What would Brian Sacca, Brooke Dillman, and Ally Maki choose, collectively, if they could only bring five movies to a desert island? The results range from the popular to the dark, with Sacca perhaps deliberately trying to throw a few wrenches into the ol’ desert island DVD collection.

Brought to you by TBS Wrecked

Season two of Wrecked is airing now on TBS. You can catch up on the whole series on TBS.com.