Katie Rife and John Teti bid farewell to True Detective’s second year in today’s DVR Club video, and even Katie—a skeptic at times during this season—finds herself singing the praises of this much-maligned sophomore effort. Our staffers analyze the many ways in which the season finale finished strong, pitch potential spinoffs to the HBO brass, and ask Chad Velcoro why he won’t return our emails.

Thank you for watching True Detective DVR Club this season!