After a two-year hiatus, supernatural horror series Outcast finally brings its second season to the U.S. (it already aired in the U.K.) Created by The Walking Dead’s Robert Kirkman, Outcast centers around Kyle Barnes, a young father who’s been plagued by demonic possession for his entire life, and the supernatural manifestations haunting the small town of Rome. In honor of the second season premiering, we sat down with Kirkman and executive producer Chris Black to play “What’s Scarier?,” a game where we pit two scary things against one another and let the the horror experts decide which is more terrifying.