This Game Of Thrones post is written from the point of view of someone who has not read the books the series is based on. As such, spoilers are strictly forbidden. Any spoilers in comments will be deleted on sight. If you see spoilers, please mark them as best you can and email eadams at avclub dot com or contact Erik on Twitter, and he’ll take care of them as soon as possible. Remember: Discussions of things that were different in the books or confirmations of things that won’t happen count as spoilers, too. Have you read the books and want to discuss what’s coming? That’s what our experts reviews are for.
Representing the aftershocks of an eventful fourth season, “The Wars To Come” is a dispatch from a show in “recharge and anticipate” mode. It’s there in the title, taken from an exchange between Varys and Tyrion: “I believe men of talent have a part to play in the war to come.” The dialogue this week is freighted with portent and import, words spoken in prelude to the exploits and adventures of a reduced-capacity cast. (Hell, the whole thing kicks off with a flashback that’s all about the future!) Some reductions have been made by the narrative, others by the choices of the producers: Hodor does not Hodor in the season premiere, and he will he will not Hodor at all in season five. The show’s biggest villains—Joffrey, Tywin—have fallen, and now we wait to see if the power vacuum they’ve created will be filled by previously unseen monsters or by conquering heroes.
We know of one person who won’t be filling it. Thanks to “The Wars To Come,” there’s one more menace among Game Of Thrones’ dead: Mance Rayder, the king beyond the wall, is no more. This is a season premiere bookended by mortality, beginning with a wake for Tywin Lannister and ending with Mance taking an arrow to his chest. It can’t be coincidence that each was killed by the same type of weapon, their superficial differences wiped away by the experience that unites all men. Tywin and Mance wielded immense power and commanded vast armies, and now both must be referred to in the past tense. As is so often the case on Game Of Thrones, their deaths are symbolic of a Westeros that is beginning to disappear—not that Mance deigned to recognize its existence in the first place.
And so the season premiere sets about to ask a quintessential Game Of Thrones question: When a new leader rises, what type of leader will that person be? Varys gives season five a thesis statement in the second of his scenes with Tyrion. Following a wide shot that makes the pair look very small amid the sumptuous paradise of their new home across the Narrow Sea, Varys wishes for “peace, prosperity,” and “a land where the powerful do not prey on the powerless.” His flowery words make a nice match for the idyllic surroundings.
“The Seven Kingdoms need someone stronger than Tommen, but gentler than Stannis. A monarch who can intimidate the high lords and inspire the people. A ruler loved by millions with a powerful army and the right family name.”
The back-and-forth that follows demands more time spent with the comedy duo of Conleth Hill and Peter Dinklage. It also lands on one worthy candidate who fits all of Varys’ prerequisites: Daenerys Targaryen. But Emilia Clarke’s character isn’t the only one who fits that description. Jon Snow is hitting all of those intimidate/inspire notes at Castle Black, and his actions at the conclusion of “The Wars To Come” demonstrate his deep reserves of mercy. He still has two sisters out there, and the one who appears this week just removed her last major obstacle to controlling The Eyrie, leaving Robin to fend for himself at some sort of finishing school for young megalomaniacs.
And then there’s Margaery Tyrell, who smirks and slinks her way around the premiere, torturing her mother-in-law from afar and interrupting a brother who’s being rather brazen about his sexual exploits. In the latter scene, breakin’-all-the-rules Loras argues that his sister’s scheming will lead only to an eternity with Cersei Lannister, but Margaery has other ideas. When Natalie Dormer responds with a most ominous “perhaps,” she makes Rhaegal and Viserion look like geckos. The dialogue of “The Wars To Come” weighs a ton, even when the sentences are one-word long.
The episode plays a lot of tricks of scale like that. Tyrion sees the world, but only through a hole in a crate. Daenerys’ followers yank the winged idol from the top of the pyramid, yet their queen is a speck on the screen next to pets she used to hold in her hand. Her fellow self-proclaimed monarch, Mance Rayder, is reduced in size by composition and wardrobe, appearing so small and so defeated when Jon visits him in his cell. Brienne, a knight with no lord to serve, nonetheless threatens to buckle the upper reaches of the frame when filmed from below. In an atmosphere of uncertainty, when a boy sits on the Iron Throne, the established hierarchies of Game Of Thrones are thrown into confusion, and “The Wars To Come” represents this confusion visually.
If the words of David Benioff and D.B. Weiss’ script resound with rhetoric, it’s because “The Wars To Come” is a series of stump speeches. In terms of real-world events, the season five premiere has excellent timing. With a presidential election on the horizon, the voting public is meeting (or re-meeting in many cases) the candidates who deem themselves worthy of sitting in America’s own Red Keep. It’s campaign season in Westeros, too, where the incumbents are throwing lavish parties and their longtime opponents are pulling out the pyrotechnics. Over in Meereen, Daario presses Dany on the importance of compromise. The people with money and influence are deciding which contender they’d like to throw their weight behind. Mavericks fire long shots. Insiders plot sabotage. “The Wars To Come”’s resolution depends on the decisions of a warrior, but its climax is initiated by the machinations of an advisor: Jon holds the bow, and Stannis gives the address, but Melisandre starts the fire.
There are compelling stories to be told within that context, but they’re not “The Wars To Come”’s to tell. The season premiere must serve as prologue, and it serves honorably—and given its occasional lack of stimulation, “serves” is an apt verb here. With lots of talk and little action, the episode will likely catch some flak for stalling. (Did you sense a disturbance when Sansa and Baelish’s carriage passed by Brienne and Pod right after they were talking about finding Sansa? As if millions of voices suddenly cried out, “She’s right there!”) The night ahead of Game Of Thrones is dark and full of empty pages, so Benioff and Weiss need to be sparing with what source material they have left, right?
But that’s another important aspect of that final scene. If stalling were truly at play, wouldn’t Mance’s execution be delayed for a few more episodes? His death is more than a signpost of change or a show of Jon’s leadership style—it’s also an indication that Game Of Thrones isn’t afraid to move forward with what it’s been given. As Benioff and Weiss prepare to take their show over the Wall and beyond the bounds of A Song Of Ice And Fire, it’s not as if they’ve run out of tragic shocks and epic heroism. Sometimes you just have to wait for them to get there.
And if you refuse to be that flexible? Sticking by your convictions can earn you a beautiful throne room in the type of massive stronghold Dany now occupies. But it can also get your foot soldiers killed, or yourself burned at the stake. While it contemplates the kind of leadership it will next put onscreen, the leadership behind the scenes at Game Of Thrones looks refreshingly willing to roll with the punches.
- Welcome back to The A.V. Club’s Game Of Thrones (newbies) coverage. I’m glad to be back on the beat, and glad to have you along for this voyage across the Narrow Sea of things George R.R. Martin has published. It’s stated above, but it bears repeating here: If you’ve read the books the series is based on and would like to discuss events that have yet to occur (or even the events that won’t occur in the show), we have a separate review for that type of discussion. Myles will be pleased to have you in the Game Of Thrones (experts) comments, and your fellow readers will be pleased to enjoy Game Of Thrones on their own terms. And if you’re the type of person who’s found themselves in possession of the next three episodes of season five, please keep any information about those episodes to yourself.
- These characters feel increasingly without adversary. Roose Bolton is alluded to, but with Tywin on a slab and Mance Rayder at the stake, Cersei stands tallest among the show’s villains. The beginning of every new Game Of Thrones season feels like a bit of a refresh, but this one requires more recalibration than most.
- There’s probably a whole separate essay to be written about how every one of Cersei’s insecurities is rooted in that fateful encounter with the witch. At the very least, it gives us the very Cersei put-down “You’re not terrifying—you’re boring.”
- In the first four scenes of the premiere, there’s blood, a corpse, vomit, nudity, and more blood. Game Of Thrones is back, baby!
- “I’m not a knight, that means you’re not a squire.” Other things Brienne is not: a) Podrick’s mother, b) happy with the current state of her sword, c) considering that any carriage that passes by might be carrying Sansa.
- Varys gives Tyrion two choices: Drink himself to death in Pentos, or join him on the journey to meet Dany. Tyrion finds a third option, though: “Can I drink myself to death on the road to Mereen?”