Sure, it’s all fun and games, until Captain Flint sends someone to put his peg leg through your skull. This trailer for season three of Starz’ Black Sails features all the foul-smelling gents (and ladies) you know and love, plus a few new faces, most notably Ray Stevenson, joining the cast this year as Blackbeard. Jack Rackham looks to be carrying on a plan of his own, while John Silver clearly has his work cut out for him, too. It’s unclear just how much punishment Nassau will take this time around, but if the past two seasons are any indication, it’s probably not going to be settled with tea time and a rousing game of Boggle. The new season sets sail January 2016.