As an accomplished actor of stage and screen—you might know him as Malcolm Merlyn on CW’s Arrow—John Barrowman is used to assuming new identities. But it wasn’t until his appearance on Pick A Choice that we learned of John’s most daring role yet: He has secretly been living a double life as a sex cyborg. This hidden truth creates startling implications for John’s game, as we are forced to consider what might happen if he had a Westworld-style freakout in his local supermarket’s produce section.

In each round of Pick A Choice, our guest draws two cards from a deck filled with famous names (both real and fictional) and one card from a deck of scenarios. Then it’s time for the guest to decide who they’d rather pick in the given scenario. For instance, would R2-D2 or Johnny Five be a better choice to tend bar at your wedding reception?

If you haven’t seen previous installments of Pick A Choice, here’s a link to remedy your sad plight.